High School

Which of the following is not an ethical issue relating to heterologous artificial insemination from the consequentialist perspective?

1) Donor Nationality
2) Marital Status
3) Donor Screening
4) Donor Identity

Answer :

Final answer:

From a consequentialist perspective, Donor Nationality is not an ethical concern relating to heterologous artificial insemination because the nationality of the donor does not have a direct impact on the outcome of the insemination process. Therefore correct option 1) Donor Nationality

Explanation:

The question revolves around the ethical considerations associated with heterologous artificial insemination from a consequentialist point of view. Consequentialism is a normative ethical theory that suggests the consequences of one's conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of that conduct. Thus, from a consequentialist perspective, the focus would be on the outcomes of the insemination process rather than the attributes of the individuals involved. Considering the options provided:

  • Donor Nationality - This is not an ethical concern from a consequentialist perspective, as the nationality of the donor would not generally have a direct impact on the outcome of the insemination process.
  • Marital Status - This could be an ethical concern if it affects the social and familial outcomes for the child and parents.
  • Donor Screening - This is an ethical concern because it has implications for the health and well-being of the child and the recipient.
  • Donor Identity - This may be an ethical concern due to potential psychological and social impacts on the child if their genetic origins are unknown.

Therefore, Donor Nationality is the option that is not an ethical issue from a consequentialist perspective, as it does not bear a significant consequence on the wellbeing of the involved parties.