High School

**Business Law**

Please answer in detail.

---

Over the last six months, John has lost fifty pounds. He is about ten pounds shy of his 200 lbs. goal weight. He has been told that the last ten pounds are the hardest to lose, but John persists.

In an effort to reach his goal weight, John joins the "Ucan-Do-It" gym (UCAN) in Manhattan. When he enrolled, he was advised to use the "Exorciser" Model XYZ, the latest model of a treadmill, manufactured by the MeltAway Corp. (MAC), which UCAN bought five months ago from Bodywill Distributors. UCAN regularly purchases equipment made by MeltAway Corp. (MAC).

John is exercising vigorously on the Exorciser when a belt snaps on the treadmill, which causes the treadmill to stop abruptly. John is thrown from the Exorciser and suffers severe injuries. As a result of the fall, John breaks his pelvis and fractures his right elbow and right wrist. John is right-handed and this fracture impedes his ability to write, dress, and drive the car. He is still hospitalized and will require extensive physical therapy after he is discharged from the hospital. He is told by his doctor that it is presently unclear whether he will make a complete recovery. Because of this unfortunate turn of events, John has become quite moody and depressed.

John retains Jane, a well-known attorney with twenty years’ experience as a litigator. She discovers the following:

1. MAC, the manufacturer of the new model treadmill, decided to use a lower grade plastic instead of the heavy-duty grade plastic band it usually uses in order to save $3.00 per treadmill.
2. MAC issued a completely revised new user’s manual which was taped to the console of the treadmill. The new user’s manual contained multiple warnings, in bold print and in red ink, which warned that users not exceed the maximum speed beyond 20 minutes of use. John was exercising on the treadmill for 40 minutes at the maximum speed when he was thrown from the treadmill.
3. Clement, an employee at UCAN, who unpacked and assembled the treadmill, discarded the user’s manual without showing it to the UCAN supervisor.
4. Per MAC directions, UCAN was to have the treadmill serviced, as part of its regular maintenance, after four months from the date of purchase. UCAN decided to save on service fees and did not have the treadmill serviced in accordance with the MAC instructions.
5. John also tells you that when he applied for membership at UCAN, Lisa, the sales rep at the gym, told John that he could easily drop ten to fifteen pounds in six weeks if he adhered to a four-times-a-week exercise regimen. John insists that Lisa never fully explained the exercise protocols. Lisa, however, denies John’s claims and says that she spent at least one hour explaining these protocols, and in fact, she gave him detailed written instructions.

Detail and explain all of the various potential claims by John included in the facts. What defenses can be made by UCAN? By MAC?

Answer :

Business law is a branch that deals with the rules, regulations, and laws governing businesses and commercial transactions. Legal cases are complex, and the actual outcomes may vary based.

Potential claims by John:

1. Product Liability against MAC: John may have a product liability claim against MAC for using a lower-grade plastic, which resulted in the treadmill belt snapping and causing his injuries.

2. Negligence against UCAN: John can claim negligence against UCAN for not properly maintaining the treadmill as per MAC's instructions, leading to the malfunction and his injuries.

3. Failure to Warn against MAC and UCAN: John may assert that both MAC and UCAN failed to adequately warn him about the risks associated with using the treadmill beyond 20 minutes at maximum speed.

4. Negligent Hiring against UCAN: John could claim that UCAN was negligent in hiring Clement, who discarded the user's manual without informing the supervisor.

Defences by UCAN:

1. Assumption of Risk: UCAN may argue that John voluntarily assumed the risk of using the treadmill, knowing the potential dangers associated with intense exercise, as indicated in the user's manual.

2. Contributory Negligence: UCAN could claim that John's failure to follow the treadmill's usage guidelines and exceeding the recommended time contributed to the accident.

3. Waiver of Liability: UCAN might have a waiver or release of liability agreement signed by John upon joining the gym, attempting to limit their responsibility for injuries sustained during exercise.

4. Denial of Misrepresentation: UCAN may contend that Lisa did provide adequate instructions and protocols, and it was John's responsibility to follow them correctly.

Defences by MAC:

1. Misuse of the Product: MAC could argue that John misused the treadmill by using it for 40 minutes at maximum speed, which goes beyond the recommended time in the new user's manual.

2. Comparative Negligence: MAC may claim that John's failure to read and follow the warnings and instructions in the new user's manual contributed to the accident and his injuries.

3. Compliance with Industry Standards: MAC might assert that the treadmill met industry standards and regulations at the time of manufacture, and the decision to use a lower-grade plastic was not unreasonable given market practices.

To know more about Business law visit:

https://brainly.com/question/31007030

#SPJ11