• Law
College

If a Court of Appeal issues a decision and the opinion is written by only one Justice who signs the opinion, and the other Justices agree but do not write supporting or contesting opinions, the opinion is considered to be what type of opinion?

A. Unanimous Opinion
B. Plurality Opinion
C. Majority Opinion
D. Per Curiam Opinion

Answer :

Final answer:

The opinion from one Justice, with agreements from other Justices who do not write their own, is a Unanimous Opinion, indicating total consensus. A Majority Opinion involves over half of the Justices agreeing, while a Plurality Opinion lacks a clear majority. Understanding these terms helps clarify court rulings.


Explanation:

Understanding Court Opinions

In the scenario presented, the opinion written by only one Justice, with agreement from other Justices who do not write their own opinions, is considered to be a Unanimous Opinion. This type of opinion reflects that all participating Justices agree with the decision made, even if only one Justice authored the opinion.

To clarify the other options:

  1. Majority Opinion - This is written when more than half of the Justices agree on the decision, requiring at least five Justices in the Supreme Court.
  2. Plurality Opinion - This occurs when no majority is established, meaning a larger group of Justices agrees on the outcome, but not on the reasoning.
  3. Per Curiam Opinion - This refers to an unsigned opinion issued by the court as a whole, where no individual Justice is credited.

In summary, a Unanimous Opinion indicates complete agreement among the Justices on the ruling made, showcasing a united court decision.


Learn more about Court Opinions here:

https://brainly.com/question/36595766