High School

Evaluate Confucius' belief of "uprightness" in 13.18 and compare it to the modern concept of "snitching." Do you agree more with the Lord of She or Confucius?

Answer :

For Confucius, "uprightness" is related to protecting those who are important to an individual. This concept is contrary to the concept of "snitching" which states that wrongdoings should be reported to the authorities, regardless of the relationship between the people involved.

Why does Confucius think this way about "uprightness?"

  • Because he believes that "uprightness" must be complete in every way.
  • Because he believes that a person is honest when he protects those he loves.
  • Because he believes that in reporting the mistakes of a loved one, the individual is not honest with his own heart.

Confucius believes that seeing a loved one punished is painful, so he believes that everyone should protect those they love, even in the face of mistakes, as reporting these mistakes would be incomplete honesty and that intends to show off and not do what is right.

Learn more about Confucius:

https://brainly.com/question/1900629

#SPJ1

Confucius prioritizes moral integrity over loyalty; modern society values honesty, but context determines whether reporting wrongdoing is appropriate.

In Confucius' Analects 13.18, Confucius discusses the concept of "uprightness," which involves individuals reporting wrongdoing even if it implicates their family or friends. This principle prioritizes moral integrity and the greater good over personal relationships or loyalty.

Comparing this to the modern concept of "snitching," there are similarities and differences. "Snitching" often carries a negative connotation and is associated with betraying trust or breaking loyalty, especially within certain social or cultural contexts. However, like Confucius' notion of uprightness, modern society also values honesty, integrity, and accountability. Reporting wrongdoing, especially in situations that involve harm to others or violate laws, can be seen as morally commendable.

As for whether I agree more with Confucius or the Lord of She, it depends on the specific circumstances. While loyalty and trust are important values, I believe that upholding moral principles and the well-being of society should take precedence. Ultimately, individuals must carefully consider the consequences and context of their actions when deciding whether to report wrongdoing.