High School

Write an argument that addresses the discussion prompt:

Consider the different justices' opinions about affirmative action. Whose opinion do you agree with most? Write one or two paragraphs stating your position. Cite points made in the opinions and explain your reasoning.

Answer :

Final answer:

I support Justice Sonia Sotomayor's dissenting opinion on affirmative action, which emphasizes the necessity of race-conscious measures to ensure educational equity. Her arguments highlight the value of diversity in educational settings and the importance of addressing systemic inequities. By supporting affirmative action, we can promote a more inclusive environment for all students.


Explanation:

Support for Justice Sonia Sotomayor's Opinion on Affirmative Action

I align most closely with Justice Sonia Sotomayor's dissenting opinion regarding affirmative action. She argues that the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees racial equality and that race-conscious measures are necessary to counteract systemic inequities in a society that is not colorblind. In her dissent, she points to landmark cases such as Grutter v. Bollinger and Brown v. Board of Education, asserting that these precedents established the validity of using limited race considerations to foster diversity and equal educational opportunities. Her viewpoint resonates with me because it acknowledges the persistent disparities that exist in education and employment based on racial backgrounds.

Furthermore, Sotomayor highlights how affirmative action benefits not only underrepresented minorities but enhances the educational experience for all students by facilitating a racially diverse learning environment. This diversity prepares students for real-world interactions and fosters mutual understanding among different cultural backgrounds. While the majority opinion leans towards a "colorblind" approach that may overlook these complexities, the call for a nuanced understanding of race in college admissions remains pertinent in ensuring equity and inclusivity. Therefore, I support Justice Sotomayor's stance advocating for the continuation of affirmative action as a necessary tool to combat ingrained institutional disadvantages.


Learn more about Affirmative Action here:

https://brainly.com/question/50896781