High School

Which of the following is a characteristic of a majority opinion?

A. The chief justice usually writes the majority opinion if they are a part of the majority.

B. All justices who are a part of the majority are required to write a majority opinion.

C. A majority opinion is only written if the justices are in universal agreement on a case.

D. Justices who are not a part of the majority must eventually agree with the majority opinion.

Answer :

Final answer:

A majority opinion is primarily written by the chief justice if they are part of the majority. Other justices in the majority do not have to write opinions, and dissenting justices can express differing views. The majority opinion reflects the consensus of those justices who support the decision.


Explanation:

Understanding the Majority Opinion in Court Decisions

A majority opinion is a crucial component of judicial decisions in courts, particularly in the Supreme Court of the United States. Among the statements provided, the correct characteristic of a majority opinion is: The chief justice usually writes the majority opinion if they are a part of the majority. This means that if the chief justice agrees with the decision that has garnered the most votes among the justices, they typically take on the responsibility of drafting the majority opinion.

Clarifying Other Statements

To further clarify the other statements:

  1. All justices who are a part of the majority are not required to write a majority opinion. In fact, only one majority opinion is usually drafted, although other justices can write concurring opinions if they wish.
  2. A majority opinion is not written only if justices are in universal agreement. It represents the views of the majority, regardless of how much disagreement exists among other justices.
  3. Justices who are not part of the majority do not have to agree with the majority opinion. They can write dissenting opinions that express their differing viewpoints.

In summary, the majority opinion is a reflection of the consensus reached by the justices who voted in favor of a decision, and it is typically authored by the chief justice when they are part of that consensus.


Learn more about Majority Opinion here:

https://brainly.com/question/6462598