College

What would most clearly be a negative source analogue for the following argument?

"Boxing is similar to wrestling because they are both forms of combat. So since boxing is a sport, wrestling must be a sport as well."

A. Karate
B. War
C. Fist
D. Sumo wrestling
E. Reading

Answer :

Final answer:

The argument concludes wrestling is a sport based on its similarity to boxing. A negative source analogue could be karate, as it presents a form of combat but diverges from the sport context. Other options either relate to combat or do not contradict the argument as clearly as karate does.


Explanation:

Understanding the Argument

The argument presented states that boxing is similar to wrestling because both are forms of combat, and concludes that since boxing is a sport, wrestling must also be a sport. To find a negative source analogue, we look for an example that contradicts the strength of the argument through a lack of shared qualities.

Identifying Negative Source Analogue

An example of a negative source analogue would be karate. While karate is also a form of combat, it's not a direct sport comparison to wrestling, just as it lacks the same regulated competitive structure as boxing and wrestling do; thus, demonstrating a deviation in similarity.

In contrast, options such as war, sumo wrestling, and fist do not clearly illustrate a direct contradiction to the argument yet show some level of combat relation. On the other hand, reading is a complete deviation from combat sports altogether.


Learn more about negative source analogue here:

https://brainly.com/question/22058326