Middle School

Dante is writing an argumentative essay on how the Columbian Exchange helped indigenous peoples.

Which claim is the most effective and should be included in his essay?

A. The Columbian Exchange was a big event that brought new ideas to indigenous peoples.
B. The Columbian Exchange brought horses and cows, which changed life for indigenous peoples.
C. The Columbian Exchange brought big changes for indigenous peoples, such as new ideas and religious beliefs.
D. The Columbian Exchange was beneficial for indigenous peoples because it brought horses, which improved transportation.

Answer :

The claim that the Columbian Exchange was beneficial because it brought horses, improving transportation, is the most effective for Dante's essay. It highlights a specific positive impact, emphasizing how horses revolutionized travel and societal organization for indigenous peoples.

The most effective claim for Dante's argumentative essay is: The Columbian Exchange was beneficial for indigenous peoples because it brought horses, which improved transportation. This claim effectively highlights a specific, positive impact—for instance, the introduction of horses revolutionized the way indigenous peoples traveled and organized their societies. Before the Columbian Exchange, the Americas did not have horses, and their introduction by Europeans significantly enhanced mobility and efficiency in various aspects of indigenous life, such as hunting and trading.

Final answer:

The Columbian Exchange brought horses and cows, which changed life for indigenous peoples.

Explanation:

The most effective claim that Dante should include in his essay is: The Columbian Exchange brought horses and cows, which changed life for indigenous peoples. This claim is effective because it provides a clear and specific example of how the Columbian Exchange impacted indigenous peoples. The introduction of horses and cows brought significant changes in transportation, agriculture, and overall lifestyle for indigenous communities. Dante can support this claim by providing specific examples and evidence of how horses and cows improved the lives of indigenous peoples.