High School

**Assignment III: Persuasive Writing in Context**

**Suggested time:** 40 to 50 minutes

**The Situation**

The Prosper School Council is considering requiring Grade 12 students to complete 60 hours of volunteer service as a condition for graduation. Supporters of the proposal believe that involving students in the community through volunteerism will encourage them to become good citizens and volunteers as adults. Opponents argue that forced volunteerism is inappropriate, as it should be a personal choice rather than a mandated requirement.

In deciding whether to accept or reject the proposal, the Prosper School Council has invited concerned individuals to express their views. You are Alex Griffin, a recent graduate of Prosper High School. After considering information and opinions from various sources (see pages 14 and 15), you have reached a decision. You now need to write a persuasive speech or letter that clearly develops your position.

**The Assignment**

Write a speech or letter to persuade the Prosper School Council to either **ACCEPT** or **REJECT** the proposal to make volunteer service mandatory for graduation.

**In preparing your persuasive speech or letter, be sure to:**

- Study the information on pages 14 and 15.
- Consider your purpose and audience.
- Present a clear argument explaining the reasons behind your decision.
- Use an appropriate tone.

Remember that you must clearly and directly choose either to accept or to reject the proposal.

Answer :

Final answer:

Alex Griffin opposes the Prosper School Council's proposal for mandatory volunteer service for graduation, emphasizing that volunteerism should be a personal choice. Mandating service may lead to resentment and stress among students, detracting from genuine civic engagement. Instead, promoting voluntary programs can encourage meaningful involvement without imposing requirements.


Explanation:

Persuasive Letter to Prosper School Council


Dear Members of the School Council,


My name is Alex Griffin, and as a recent graduate of Prosper High School, I would like to express my strong opposition to the proposal of requiring Grade 12 students to complete 60 hours of volunteer service as a condition for graduation.


While the intention behind this proposal is commendable, the reality is that volunteerism should stem from an individual's personal choice and passion, not be mandated by a school policy. Forcing students to engage in community service undermines the very essence of what makes volunteering meaningful. Instead of fostering a genuine sense of civic duty, it risks creating a culture of resentment towards community service and the notion of giving back.


Furthermore, each student's circumstances are unique. Not all students have the same opportunities or access to volunteer positions that align with their interests and skills. Imposing a requirement can lead to stress and anxiety, particularly for those who may be balancing part-time jobs, coursework, and personal responsibilities. This could ultimately detract from their academic performance and overall well-being.


Moreover, there are numerous other ways to promote civic engagement in students. By creating voluntary programs and incentives for those who wish to participate in community service, the school could encourage a more positive and authentic engagement with volunteerism, without the pressure of a mandated requirement.


In conclusion, I urge the Prosper School Council to reconsider this proposal. Volunteer service should be a choice that reflects personal commitment, not an obligation imposed upon students at a significant time in their lives. Thank you for considering my perspective.


Sincerely,
Alex Griffin


Learn more about mandatory volunteer service here:

https://brainly.com/question/42374322


Other Questions